top of page

Old vs New | Which Diesel Is Cheaper to Run?

Writer: Dan
Dan
Nov 9
3 min read

In our gas-versus-diesel comparison, I had to work out what a gas truck would need to get because I don't own one to log. This time I have fuel records from both trucks.


Ursula is our 2003 Ford F-250 King Ranch with the 6.0 Power Stroke.


Jolene is our 2024 Ford F-350 Super Duty with the 6.7 Power Stroke.


I wanted to see what happened once diesel, DEF and routine maintenance all landed on the same page.


The best tank each Power Stroke ever logged


Best single-tank fuel economy. Ursula drove 329 km on 30.9 L for 25.0 US MPG. Jolene drove 469.4 km on 46.68 L for 23.7 US MPG

Ursula's best run was 329 km (204.4 mi) on 30.9 L (8.16 US gal). Jolene went 469.4 km (291.7 mi) on 46.68 L (12.33 US gal) on her best run. She was still on factory tires and the camper hadn't gone on yet.


I'd happily take either number. I just wouldn't use one fill-up to work out what either truck costs me on a regular basis.


What the longer fuel logs showed


Average fuel economy from separate mixed-driving logs. Ursula averaged 15.0 US MPG over 19,052 km. Jolene averaged 16.0 US MPG over about 7,800 km.

Over roughly 19,000 km (11,800 mi) of mixed driving, Ursula averaged 15.0 US MPG (15.65 L/100 km). Jolene averaged 16.0 US MPG (14.70 L/100 km) over about 7,800 km (4,850 mi), and that's with the 37s and the Yucca-Pac camper on.


These logs cover different routes, loads and conditions. They tell me how the trucks did the way I actually used them. And with the camper on and the bigger tires, I was happy to see Jolene still using about a litre less diesel every 100 km.


What diesel and DEF cost over 1,000 km


I used $2.28 CAD per litre ($8.63 CAD per US gallon) for both trucks, the same diesel price I used in our gas versus diesel fuel economy comparison. That's the price used for the math here. The pump price has already dropped sense doing my initial comparison, but I want to give everything a fair cross reference.

Fuel and DEF costs over 1,000 km (621 mi). Ursula spends $356.88 CAD on diesel. Jolene spends $335.16 on diesel and $5.21 on DEF, for $340.37 CAD total.

Over 1,000 km (621 mi), Ursula works out to $356.88 CAD in diesel. Jolene comes in at $335.16 CAD in diesel, plus $5.21 CAD in DEF, for $340.37 CAD. The newer truck still comes out about $16.50 CAD ahead after I buy her that extra jug.


Where the old 6.0 saves on maintenance


I used the same service count over 58,218 km (36,175 mi). That means four oil changes, one fuel-filter service and one engine air filter. Both trucks use about the same amount of oil, and I use Rotella T6 and Motorcraft filters.


I also counted the cabin air filter I replaced in Jolene. Ursula lets you breathe that fresh mountain air straight from outside.

Routine DIY maintenance over 58,218 km (36,175 mi). Ursula's estimated total is $1,124.47 CAD. Jolene's recorded costs, adjusted to DIY, total $1,223.20 CAD.

Ursula's $1,124.47 CAD is an estimate based on parts prices for those services. Jolene's $1,223.20 CAD comes from our maintenance records, adjusted to DIY costs. That's $98.73 CAD in Ursula's favour over the full maintenance interval, or about $1.70 CAD per 1,000 km.


What I'd buy for the 6.0L


If I were ordering parts for Ursula, these are the two listings I'd use. For the 6.7L, I still find it easier to get Jolene's parts straight from Ford.


As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.


Which diesel is cheaper to run?

Combined costs over 1,000 km (621 mi). Ursula totals $376.19 CAD and Jolene totals $361.38 CAD. Jolene saves about $15 CAD.

Once I add diesel, DEF and routine maintenance, Jolene comes out about $15 CAD cheaper over 1,000 km (621 mi). That's about $24 CAD over 1,000 miles (1,609 km) at the same rates.


Ursula had the better single run and costs less to service in this comparison. Jolene burns enough less diesel to cover her DEF and the higher routine maintenance cost. The combined numbers are $376.19 CAD for Ursula and $361.38 CAD for Jolene over 1,000 km.


That's close enough to make me check the spreadsheet a few times. And these are running costs. The money it takes to buy a truck or deal with a major repair is a whole other conversation.


Should I have put the money into Ursula?


Ursula has 458,000 km (about 285,000 mi) on her. She's still running her factory turbo, injectors, head gaskets and emissions equipment. She's no spring chicken, and if you've seen her up close, you know the rust would have had a say in the budget too.


Still, the running costs are close enough that I keep coming back to it. Would I have been better off putting $30,000 or $40,000 into the old girl and calling it a day? I think that's another discussion for another day.


If you've gone from an old diesel to a newer one, what did you actually average in each? And knowing what you know now, would you buy the newer truck again or put the money into the old one?


And for the shameless plug, Team Ursula or Team Jolene? The money we make on each truck's shirt goes back into that truck. If you want to help us build these girls, you can find both at The Baker Adventures.

Comments


bottom of page