top of page

F-350 Maintenance Costs: Gas vs Diesel

Writer: Dan
Dan
Nov 2
6 min read

Our last gas-versus-diesel video got plenty of people talking. And one thing kept coming up in the comments.


Maintenance.


Fair point. Comparing fuel and DEF tells us what it costs to drive down the road, but the oil and filters need paying for too.


So I opened the spreadsheet again to compare our F-350 maintenance costs.


This time, we're comparing what we've actually spent maintaining our 2024 F-350 diesel with an estimate for the same services on a 7.3 gas truck. Then we're putting those numbers back into the fuel comparison to see what maintenance really adds.



Our Actual F-350 Maintenance Costs Over 58,218 km


Jolene is our standard-output 2024 Ford F-350 with the 6.7 Power Stroke. We're running 37-inch tires without a lift and a Yucca-Pac Safari camper. It's our daily driver and the truck we use to get our family of six out adventuring.


For this maintenance comparison, we've covered 58,218 km since delivery, approximately 36,175 miles.


The records include four oil services, a fuel-filter replacement, an engine air filter and a cabin air filter. One service was done at Ford. The rest I did myself.

F-350 diesel maintenance over 58,218 km: CAD $1,280.47 paid, or $1,223.20 and $2.10 per 100 km after adjusting the dealer service to a DIY basis.
Our recorded routine maintenance total, followed by the adjustment used to compare both trucks on a DIY basis. All prices are Canadian dollars.

The actual receipt total is $1,280.47, or approximately $2.20 per 100 km. That includes $45 in dealer labour. Ford also charged $71.98 for the oil filter at that visit, compared with the $59.71 I pay when buying the Ford filter myself.


To compare doing the work ourselves on both trucks, I've removed that labour and the $12.27 filter-price difference.


That leaves $1,223.20, or $2.10 per 100 km, as the diesel maintenance figure used throughout the comparison.


The Oil and Filters I'm Using

I haven't been chasing the cheapest possible diesel oil change. I've used Shell Rotella T6 5W-40 since new and a Ford oil filter each time.


generally change the oil around 30–40% life remaining on the monitor, or before a major trip if I want it fresh before we head out. That's my approach to maintaining this truck, rather than a claim that every owner needs to follow the same timing.


Ford drained the fuel-filter water separator at the dealer service around 21,000 km. I replaced the fuel filters at approximately 48,000 km.


The cabin filter was replaced around 54,000 km. It actually looked fairly clean, but there was a smell inside the cab. With four kids, identifying a smell can be an investigation all on its own. Replacing the filter cleared that one up.


What This Total Leaves Out

There has been warranty work on Jolene, including a rear differential rebuild. The recorded warranty repairs cost us nothing out of pocket, so they aren't added to this paid maintenance total.


That doesn't mean nothing has needed fixing. It means this comparison measures our paid routine maintenance.


Tires are separate, and DEF gets added below. We're also leaving future repairs out of the calculation for both engines.


What Would the Same Maintenance Cost on a 7.3 Gas?


I don't own a 7.3 gas truck. Maybe if we sell enough shirts, we can buy one and give it its own spreadsheet. For now, this side is a priced estimate, rather than another truck's recorded ownership history.


I also wanted the oil choice to be reasonably comparable. I'm using T6 in the diesel, so I've priced premium Pennzoil Ultra Platinum 5W-30 for the gas truck, along with Ford filters.


We're matching the four oil services over the same distance. That is a comparison assumption, rather than a claim that every 7.3 owner needs exactly four changes in 58,000 km.

Estimated Ford 7.3 gas maintenance over 58,218 km: 4 oil changes, Ford filters and a cabin filter total CAD $584.49, approximately $1.00 per 100 km.
The proposed gas maintenance budget uses premium synthetic oil, Ford filters and the same service count and distance as the diesel comparison.

The gas calculation uses 7.57 litres of oil per change. The Ford oil-filter quote was $16.76 before the filter levy and GST, and the engine air-filter quote was $66.25 before GST.


We've included Alberta's 5% GST, the $1.25 oil-filter levy and the $2.70 oil levy per change. The cabin filter uses the same $59.20 tax-included cost as mine.


The oil amount is based on what gets used. Oil left in a jug carries into the next service, so this isn't the upfront checkout cost of buying whole jugs.


And yes, we checked the gasoline fuel filter. Ford's scheduled-maintenance information describes it as an integrated lifetime filter without a scheduled replacement, so there isn't a matching fuel-filter service to add to this gas budget.


The result is approximately $1.00 per 100 km for gas maintenance, compared with $2.10 per 100 km for the diesel on a DIY basis.


Gas wins that part. The difference is $638.71 over the recorded distance. Spread out, that's about $1.10 per 100 km, or roughly $11 per 1,000 km.


What Happens When We Add Fuel and DEF?


In our previous F-350 fuel economy comparison, we used $2.28/L diesel and $1.59/L gasoline.


Those same prices stay in this calculation so we can see what adding maintenance changes. They are comparison prices, rather than a claim about today's pump price.

For readers using US gallons, that's CAD $8.63 per US gallon for diesel and CAD $6.02 per US gallon for gasoline. The unit changes; the currency stays Canadian.

Our recorded camper fuel average is 14.70 L/100 km, approximately 16.0 US MPG. At $2.28/L, that puts diesel fuel at $33.52 per 100 km. Add approximately $0.52 for DEF and $2.10 for maintenance.

Fuel, DEF and maintenance per 100 km: diesel CAD $36.14; gas $32.17 at 12 US MPG and $29.77 at 13 US MPG. Gas breaks even at 22.10 L/100 km or 10.64 US MPG.
Fuel, DEF and routine maintenance combined at the stated pump prices. The gas fuel-economy figures are hypothetical scenarios.

This combines our historical maintenance rate with the later camper fuel average and the stated pump prices. It isn't our actual average bill for every kilometre since delivery.

With those assumptions, the gas truck needs 22.10 L/100 km or better, equivalent to 10.64 US MPG or better, to match or beat our diesel's combined running cost.


Lower litres per hundred, or higher MPG, favours gas. Higher consumption favours diesel.


What If Your Gas Truck Gets Different Mileage?


Twelve or thirteen MPG might be useful examples, but your truck could land somewhere else entirely.

That's why the next chart runs from eight through sixteen US MPG, with litres per hundred beside each figure.

Gas running costs at 8–16 US MPG, with L/100 km equivalents, compared with diesel at CAD $361.38 per 1,000 km. Gas saves $39.68 at 12 MPG and $63.66 at 13 MPG.
Find your calculated gas consumption and compare the combined cost over 1,000 km, approximately 620 miles.

A thousand kilometres is a useful benchmark for our mountain trips. Saving forty or sixty dollars on one of those trips matters to our family's travel budget.


But I haven't measured a 7.3 gas truck with our tires, camper, family and gear. These figures show what different gas consumption rates would cost. They don't prove which rate an equivalent truck would achieve.


That's where I'd like to hear from owners actually running those setups.


What If Diesel Gets Cheaper?


Hopefully diesel doesn't stay at these prices forever. The difference between the two pump prices can move this comparison around considerably.

For this last chart, gasoline stays at $1.59/L. Diesel consumption, DEF and maintenance also stay fixed. Only the diesel pump price changes.

Diesel prices of CAD $2.28, $2.00, $1.80 and $1.59 per litre, also shown per US gallon, with running costs and gas break-even figures. Gas stays at $1.59/L.
Illustrative diesel-price scenarios, with gas held at CAD $1.59/L / $6.02 per US gallon. These are scenarios, not a price forecast.

At $2.00 diesel, the 12-MPG gas example is almost level with us again.


At $1.80/L diesel, gas needs to achieve approximately 13.32 US MPG to match the diesel's combined cost.


And at equal pump prices, gas needs almost 15 US MPG. In that scenario, the twelve- and thirteen-MPG gas examples cost more to run than our diesel, even after including its higher maintenance and DEF.


Would I Buy the Diesel Again?


I still like what Jolene does for us. We bought it to run the tires, carry the camper, load up the family and travel.


But at $2.28/L diesel and $1.59/L gas, a gas truck achieving twelve or thirteen US MPG is cheaper in this comparison. Adding maintenance moves the numbers a little further in that direction.


The maintenance difference is real. The fuel bill is still the much bigger part of the trip cost, and changes at the pump can shift which engine comes out ahead.


We haven't settled the whole ownership question. Purchase price, depreciation and future repairs still sit outside this calculation. What we have is our paid maintenance, a priced gas estimate and a way to compare different fuel prices and consumption figures.


So, gas owners, show me your numbers. Engine, tire size, camper or trailer, calculated fuel economy and the kind of driving you're doing. Litres per hundred or US MPG both work.


Diesel owners, what are you paying for oil changes? Doing it yourself or taking it in? Include your currency so we can compare properly.


And should we see how much I can cut this maintenance bill by changing my choice of oil and filters while still meeting Ford's requirements? Maybe it's time to price an alternative to my mocha latte oil and tuxedo-black Ford filters.


Help Keep the Adventures Going

If you enjoy the truck builds, gear reviews and the occasional spreadsheet rabbit hole, take a look at our Baker Adventures merchandise.


We've got the Alien Sasquatch, camping designs and the shirt I'm wearing in this video: for every mile of road, there's two miles of ditch.


Find something that suits your style and help us keep the family out adventuring. Apparently retirement now comes with an oil-filter budget.

Comments


bottom of page